1-888-601-9980
- In Canada, 90% of health insurance policies are acquired through group benefits plans, making them the primary method for churches to provide comprehensive coverage to pastors
- Typical group plans for pastors encompass extended health care, dental, vision, prescription drugs, mental health services, disability benefits, and life insurance, addressing the unique needs of clergy members
- Churches can select from various benefit structures, including denominational group plans, independent custom packages, Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs), Health Spending Accounts (HSAs), and taxable stipends, to suit their size and budget
- Premiums paid by churches for group health benefits are generally non-taxable for employees, but churches should maintain detailed records for CRA compliance
- Why is group health insurance important for churches and pastors?
- What are the essential group health insurance coverages for pastors in Canada?
- What group employee benefits options do Canadian churches have?
- What is the cost of group health insurance for church employees?
- What is the minimum staff requirement for group health insurance plans?
- What are the tax considerations for churches offering group health benefits?
- How can churches manage rising group health insurance premiums?
- What are the alternative employee benefit options for churches in Canada?
- How to choose the right group health insurance for church employees?
- Frequently asked questions
Group health insurance for pastors in Canada protects the well-being of clergy serving faith communities. According to research by the CHLIA in 2022, 90% of health insurance policies in Canada were purchased as part of a group benefits plan.
Churches choose group health insurance to deliver comprehensive coverage to clergy while controlling costs. In this guide, we’ll discuss Canadian group medical insurance for churches and pastors, its benefits, costs, and flexible alternatives.
Call 1-888-601-9980 to speak to our licensed advisors right away, or book some time with them below.
Why is group health insurance important for churches and pastors?
Churches offer health insurance for pastors and staff as a part of their employee benefits program to showcase commitment, compassion, and a long-term vision for ministry. Health insurance for pastors helps with fulfilling their unique demands, providing coverage even with varying employment status.
Providing employee benefits to pastors strengthens staff well-being, boosts morale, and positions the church as a responsible employer in both spiritual and practical terms.
Here are a few reasons why church health insurance fir clergy in Canada is important:
- Pastors face unique demands: They often work irregular hours, carry emotional burdens, and struggle to find personal time. Accessible physical and mental health care becomes essential
- Employment status varies: Many pastors operate in a dual capacity—as employees and self-employed ministers, making it difficult to access standard health plans. Churches must find tailored solutions
- Health security protects ministry continuity: Reliable insurance helps pastors and staff cover medical expenses and maintain overall wellness
- Strong benefits support recruitment and retention: When churches offer group health benefits, they increase their ability to attract and keep experienced, committed ministry professionals
- Benefits align with mission and values: Caring for leaders reflects Christian principles of spreading kindness, compassion, and service
What are the essential group health insurance coverages for pastors in Canada?
Most church health benefits plans in Canada include core health coverage such as hospital visits, dental care, vision care, prescription drug coverage, etc. These plans also include optional features like chiropractic care, mental health services, disability payout, and accidental death and dismemberment (AD&D) coverage, etc.
- Extended health benefits: These plans typically include prescription drug coverage, hospital stays, paramedical services like massage therapy, chiropractic care, and physiotherapy, as well as durable medical equipment
- Dental care: Churches often provide basic and preventive dental care such as cleanings, exams, fillings, and extractions. Some plans also cover more advanced procedures like crowns or root canals
- Vision care: Though optional, many health insurance plans for church employees include coverage for eye exams, glasses, or contact lenses, especially helpful for aging clergy
- Prescription drug coverage: Coverage for medication is critical to managing both chronic and acute conditions. It often falls under extended health care
- Mental health services: Pastors often carry emotional and spiritual burdens. Plans that offer counseling, therapy, or psychological support are essential to promote mental wellness
- Short-term and long-term disability: These benefits offer income replacement if a pastor becomes unable to work due to injury or illness. While sometimes optional, they are highly recommended for financial stability
- Life insurance and accidental death & dismemberment (AD&D): These benefits offer financial protection to a pastor’s family in case of death or serious injury
What group employee benefits options do Canadian churches have?
Canadian churches offer group employee benefits through diverse options, including small business group plans, denominational plans, independent custom plans, HRAs, taxable stipends, HSAs, and association-based coverage
1. Group insurance plans
Many denominations and Christian associations offer group health insurance for pastors and families. These group plans often include:
- Extended health care (prescriptions, vision, paramedical)
- Dental coverage
- Life insurance and AD&D
- Short- and long-term disability coverage
These plans provide comprehensive coverage and simplify administration, especially when the provider manages everything centrally.
2. Denominational benefit plans
Large denominations, such as the United Church of Canada, the Catholic Church, and Presbyterian ministries, often offer standardized health plans for their pastors and lay employees. These benefit programs promote consistency, affordability, and alignment with the church’s organizational structure.
3. Independent group plans
Independent or non-denominational churches can partner with private insurers to create custom group benefit packages. These plans allow flexibility in choosing specific coverages like health, dental, vision, and disability insurance. Most of the mid-sized Christian congregations often find this approach effective for their staffing needs.
4. Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs)
HRAs give churches a flexible and tax-efficient way to support pastors without committing to a full insurance plan. With HRAs, churches reimburse eligible medical expenses and premiums on a tax-free basis. The HRA model works especially well for small congregations with tight budgets.
5. Taxable stipends
When churches cannot offer formal insurance, they may choose to provide a monthly stipend. Pastors can then use this amount to buy individual health insurance. Though this option lacks tax-free benefits, it offers flexibility and respects the autonomy of self-employed pastors.
6. Health Spending Accounts (HSAs)
HSAs allow churches to set aside a fixed amount per employee for eligible medical expenses. They work as a tax-efficient alternative to full insurance and allow staff to manage their care independently. HSAs provide predictability for churches and flexibility for pastors.
7. Association-based coverage
Faith-based associations like the Canadian Council of Christian Charities often make group health coverage accessible to member churches. These plans help smaller churches access affordable benefits by pooling risk across multiple organizations.
What is the cost of group health insurance for church employees?
The cost of group health insurance for church employees in Canada varies based on the size of the church, the number of staff members, and the type of plan selected. Larger churches usually pay lower premiums per employee, whereas smaller churches may pay higher per-employee rates due to limited group size and fewer cost-sharing advantages.
Cost of group benefits for church employees in Canada
| Church size (by staff) | Estimated monthly premium (Per employee) | Typical coverage inclusions |
| Small churches (1–50 employees) | $250 – $350 | Prescription drugs, extended health care, basic dental, vision care, some paramedical services |
| Medium churches (51–200 employees) | $200 – $300 | Broader drug and dental coverage, vision, semi-private/private hospital, EAP, etc |
| Large churches (201+ employees) | $150 – $250 | Comprehensive benefits like high drug and dental limits, EAP, critical illness, life insurance, etc |
What is the minimum staff requirement for group health insurance plans?
In Canada, most insurance providers require churches to have at least a minimum of 3 to 5 eligible employees to qualify for a group health insurance plan. This group may include pastors, administrative staff, and other full-time or salaried employees within the church.
If your church doesn’t meet this threshold, consider joining a pooled plan through your denomination or a ministry association. You can also explore alternatives like HSAs or taxable stipends to provide health support more flexibly.
What are the tax considerations for churches offering group health benefits?
Churches must consider tax implications when offering group health benefit plans to their employees, especially since most operate as registered charities in Canada. Even with charitable status, they must remain compliant with CRA guidelines regarding employee compensation.
- Tax treatment of premiums: Group health benefits (including extended health, dental, vision, life, and disability) are usually non-taxable for employees when the church pays the premiums
- Charitable status impacts: Offering reasonable employee benefits does not affect a church’s charitable status. As long as the group benefits are at par with other industries and strengthen the organization’s religious mission, the CRA considers it appropriate
- Tax-efficient compensation planning: Churches can combine tax-free group benefits with modest stipends to create well-rounded compensation packages for pastors and other employees
- CRA documentation requirements: To ensure compliance with the CRA guidelines, churches should have a few mandatory documents:
- Keep written benefit plan documents
- Maintain formal employment contracts that describe offered benefits
- Record premium payments accurately in the financial books
- Issue T4 slips that reflect any taxable allowances or benefits
Can retired pastors stay on the church’s group employee benefits plan?
Some group health insurance plans allow retired pastors to stay covered through continuation or retiree plans. However, eligibility depends on the insurer’s rules and how the original policy was set up.
If continuation coverage is unavailable, churches can support retired pastors by offering a Health Spending Account or a taxable stipend. Planning ahead for retirement health care ensures pastors receive long-term support and honors their years of faithful service.
What are the alternative employee benefit options for churches in Canada?
Apart from offering traditional health insurance, Canadian churches can explore alternative benefits to support the well-being of pastors and staff. These options include wellness programs, EAPs, sabbatical policies, and retirement planning benefits. Offering such group benefits can enhance overall care, boost morale, and align with the church’s mission and resources.
- Health care sharing ministries: Though limited in Canada, some faith-based groups pool resources to cover members’ medical costs, an alternative to insurance for smaller congregations
- Wellness programs: Initiatives promoting physical, mental, and spiritual health (e.g., gym subsidies, stress management workshops) encourage holistic well-being
- Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs): EAPs offer confidential support for mental health, family, and financial issues, valuable for emotionally demanding ministry roles
- Sabbatical policies: Providing structured time off for rest and renewal can serve as a powerful health and retention benefit for clergy
- Retirement planning integration: Including RRSP matching or pension contributions as part of a broader benefits strategy supports long-term financial health for pastors
How to choose the right group health insurance for church employees?
Selecting the best group health insurance for pastors involves balancing the unique needs of your church with practical considerations like budget, coverage, and administration. Whether you’re a small independent church or part of a larger denomination, finding the right plan requires thoughtful comparison and planning.
- Size of congregation and staff: Larger churches may benefit from full group plans, while smaller ones might opt for Health Spending Accounts or stipends
- Budget and affordability: Evaluate what your church can realistically afford in monthly premiums and out-of-pocket costs
- Denominational requirements or options: Some denominations offer or require participation in group benefit programs, often at reduced rates
- Flexibility for part-time or bi-vocational pastors: Ensure the plan accommodates pastors with irregular employment status or multiple roles
- Ease of administration and provider reputation: Choose a provider known for responsive service, simple claims processes, and reliable coverage options
How to get the best group health insurance quotes for pastors in Canada?
To get the best group health insurance quotes for pastors in Canada, churches should consider working with insurance experts who can offer customised solutions for their diverse group health insurance needs!
PolicyAdvisor partners with over 30+ top insurers in Canada to help churches create health plans based on their unique needs. Our advisors can guide churches and clergymen in choosing the right mix of coverage that can help with their overall physical and mental health requirements.
With PolicyAdvisor, churches can easily compare quotes, control costs, and build strong, well-rounded health protection for their team. Schedule a call with us today to know more!
Frequently Asked Questions
What happens to a pastor’s benefits if they move to a new church?
If the new church uses the same group insurance provider or denominational plan, benefits may transfer smoothly. Otherwise, coverage typically ends upon leaving, and the pastor may need to requalify with the new employer. Some plans offer conversion to individual coverage or continuation options for a limited time.
Can churches reimburse pastors for personal health insurance plans?
Yes, churches can reimburse pastors for individual health insurance premiums using Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs) or taxable stipends. HRAs are more tax-efficient, but must be set up correctly to remain CRA-compliant.
Taxable stipends are easier to administer but are considered income. These options are especially useful for small churches unable to offer traditional group insurance.
Can churches join together to form a group health insurance plan?
Yes, small churches can collaborate, especially within the same denomination or ministry association, to form a multi-employer group plan. This approach helps meet minimum participant requirements, lowers premiums through pooled risk, and increases access to better coverage.
Churches should consult a benefits broker or denominational office to explore available collective options and ensure proper legal and administrative coordination.
Are mental health services included in church health plans?
Most group health insurance for pastors includes some level of mental health coverage, such as counselling, therapy, or psychologist visits, under extended health benefits. Coverage limits vary by provider.
Churches can also add Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs) to support emotional and spiritual well-being. Given the unique pressures of ministry work, mental health benefits are a vital part of a church’s support system.
Do churches have to offer health insurance by law in Canada?
No, there is no legal requirement for Canadian churches (or most employers) to offer health insurance. However, providing benefits helps attract and retain quality staff, supports well-being, and demonstrates pastoral care. Many churches voluntarily offer coverage through denominational plans or private insurers as part of a broader compensation strategy, even though it’s not mandatory under Canadian employment law.
In Canada, group health insurance is crucial for churches to support pastors’ well-being and ministry continuity. Given pastors’ unique roles and varying employment statuses, tailored health plans are essential. Core coverages typically include extended health care, dental, vision, prescription drugs, mental health services, disability, and life insurance. Churches can choose from denominational plans, independent group plans, Health Reimbursement Arrangements (HRAs), Health Spending Accounts (HSAs), or taxable stipends, depending on size and budget. Most insurers require a minimum of 3–5 eligible employees for group plans. Tax considerations are important, as premiums are usually non-taxable benefits. To manage rising premiums, churches can adjust coverage levels, increase deductibles, or combine core policies with HSAs. Retired pastors may retain coverage through continuation plans or receive support via HSAs or stipends. Alternative benefits like wellness programs, Employee Assistance Programs (EAPs), sabbaticals, and retirement planning further enhance staff support.
Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association. Canadian Life & Health Insurance Facts: 2023 Edition. Toronto: Canadian Life and Health Insurance Association, 2023.
