1-888-601-9980
- Rising premiums, poor claims service, limited plan flexibility, lack of digital tools, and unhappy employees are clear indicators that it’s time to switch providers
- Switching group insurance in Canada takes about 30–60 days. Work with experts at PolicyAdvisor to review your current plan, compare top providers, and avoid coverage gaps
- Communicate changes early, explain the benefits of the new plan, and provide resources to help employees understand and use their coverage effectively
- Don’t focus only on price, overlook employee feedback, miss notice deadlines, or skip professional guidance, as these can lead to disruption and dissatisfaction
Employee benefits can make or break your talent strategy in Canada. According to a recent study, 84% of Canadian companies offer supplementary benefits to attract and retain employees. A strong group benefits plan not only helps you stay competitive but also improves employee satisfaction and controls costs.
But what if your current group insurance provider isn’t the right fit for you? Rising premiums, compliance issues, and unhappy employees could hurt your business.
In this guide, we’ll uncover five signs it’s time to switch your group insurance provider and explain how to make the transition smoothly.
Every business is different, and so are your group benefit needs.
Whether you’re covering a small team or a large workforce, get a customized look at insurance costs and coverage in seconds.
How much does Group Insurance cost?
What is group insurance in Canada?
Group insurance in Canada is a type of employee health and benefits plan that businesses offer to their employees under one contract. Instead of employees buying individual policies, the employer negotiates a single plan that covers the entire team. This approach lowers costs per person, provides better coverage options, and makes benefits more accessible.
A typical group insurance plan in Canada includes health insurance, dental care, vision coverage, prescription drug plans, and sometimes wellness benefits or life and disability insurance. Employers pay all or part of the premium, making it a valuable perk for employees.
When should you switch group insurance providers in Canada?
Choosing the right group insurance provider in Canada can make a big difference for both employers and employees. If your current plan no longer meets your company’s needs, it may be time to consider alternatives. Here are five clear signs it’s time to make a switch:
1. Your premiums keep increasing without added value
Are your group insurance premiums rising every year with no noticeable improvements in coverage? Annual premium hikes are common, but if your costs are increasing faster than the market average, that’s a red flag.
A good provider should justify rate adjustments with added benefits, innovative wellness programs, or better coverage. If that’s not happening, it’s time to explore more cost-effective options in Canada’s competitive group benefits market.
2. Employees are dissatisfied with the coverage
Employee satisfaction with benefits is crucial for retention and morale. If your team frequently complains about limited coverage, high out-of-pocket expenses, or difficulty using their plans, your current provider isn’t meeting expectations.
Low plan utilization and negative feedback often mean employees don’t see value in their benefits. To improve group benefits coverage, consider switching to a provider that offers more comprehensive and flexible options tailored to diverse employee needs.
3. Poor customer service and slow claims processing
Customer service can make or break the employee benefits experience. If your employees face delayed reimbursements, unresponsive support, or complicated claims processes, trust in the plan erodes quickly.
Good providers offer dedicated account managers, quick claims turnaround, and easy communication channels. On the other hand, poor insurance provider customer service and a frustrating claims experience in Canada are strong indicators that you should look elsewhere for better service standards.
4. Limited plan options and lack of flexibility
A one-size-fits-all approach no longer works for modern workplaces. If your provider doesn’t offer customizable employee health plans or flexible group benefits, your coverage may be outdated.
Today’s employees expect options like mental health support, virtual care, and wellness initiatives. If your plan lacks these features, you’re likely falling behind competitors who provide robust, personalized benefits packages.
5. Lack of digital tools or wellness support
Modern group benefits go beyond basic coverage. They integrate technology and well-being initiatives. It may be time to switch group insurance providers if your provider doesn’t offer:
- Online portals for plan administration
- Mobile apps for claims and plan information
- Wellness programs like Resilience® or Enhanced Wellness
Digital tools simplify benefits management and enhance employee engagement, while wellness support helps improve health outcomes and productivity.
How do I know if my group insurance plan is good enough?
You can determine if your group insurance plan is sufficient by assessing how well it aligns with employee needs and your business objectives. A strong plan offers comprehensive health coverage, affordable premiums, and easy claims processing. Monitor employee satisfaction, plan utilization, and out-of-pocket costs. If staff often complain about limited benefits or slow reimbursements, your plan may fall short.
Compare your coverage and premiums to other group insurance plans in Canada to ensure competitiveness. If your plan lacks flexibility, wellness options, or compliance support, it’s time to switch group insurance providers for better value and improved employee satisfaction.
How to switch group insurance providers in Canada?
Switching group insurance providers in Canada means you must analyze your current plan, compare top plans from the best providers, finalize and initiate the transition, and keep your employees aware of their new benefits. Here’s a step-by-step guide on how to switch group insurance providers in Canada:
Step 1: Assess your current plan and define your goals
Start by evaluating your existing group benefits plan. Review premium costs, claims experience, employee satisfaction, and customer service quality. Identify pain points such as frequent premium hikes or poor claims support.
Next, define your objectives and assess your workforce demographics. Younger employees might value mental health support or Healthcare Spending Accounts (HSAs), while older employees may prioritize comprehensive health and dental coverage.
Step 2: Work with an experienced group benefits broker
Partnering with a Canadian group benefits broker (such as our experts at PolicyAdvisor) streamlines the process. Our licensed advisors can help you negotiate with insurance providers like Manulife, Sun Life, Canada Life, and Desjardins. Here are a few things PolicyAdvisor can help you with:
- Benchmark your current plan against top competitors within the market
- Issue a Request for Proposal (RFP) to leading group benefits insurers
- Provide multiple quotes tailored to your business needs and employee demographics
Step 3: Compare providers and select the best fit for your business
Before switching your group insurance provider, you must focus on comparing plans from various providers. Analyze coverage details, check for the latest group insurance trends, customer service and claims settlement records to choose the best fit for your business.
- Coverage details: Deductibles, co-insurance, annual maximums, extended health, dental, and disability benefits
- Technology: Check if the provider offers an online portal, mobile app, and easy plan administration tools
- Customer service: Check claims turnaround times, support availability, and dedicated account managers
Choosing a provider with strong digital capabilities and responsive service improves employee experience and administrative efficiency.
Step 4: Finalize the transition and notify your current provider
After selecting your new group insurance provider that fits your unique requirements, you must sign the new agreement and confirm the starting dates and terms with your latest group insurance provider
Provide written notice to your current provider within the required timeframe to avoid penalties or automatic renewal. Coordinate the transition so that your insurance advisor, old provider, and new provider can exchange data efficiently to prevent coverage gaps.
Step 5: Communicate the change to employees
Once the group insurance plan is set in place, you must communicate the new transition to your employees. Educate them about their new benefits, coverage amount and additional perks to ensure they are on the right track.
- Announce the change early and explain why you switched to a different group insurance provider (e.g., better benefits, enhanced technology, or wellness programs)
- Share a summary of the new plan, highlighting improvements
- Host Q&A sessions or webinars with the group benefits broker or new provider to address concerns
- Distribute new benefits cards, booklets, and login instructions for the provider’s online portal or app
- Monitor the new plan for claims processing speed, service quality, and technology performance
- Gather employee feedback to measure satisfaction
- Schedule annual reviews with your insurance broker to keep your plan competitive, cost-effective, and aligned with employee needs
How long does it take to switch group insurance providers in Canada?
Switching group insurance providers in Canada usually takes 30–90 days, depending on contract terms, insurer, and complexity. This will allow enough time for plan review, termination notice, and employee communication. Employers typically give 30–90 days’ notice before the change, but this may vary between different providers.
For group life insurance, applications must be submitted within 31 days to avoid medical underwriting. For health and dental, options like Manulife FollowMe, Canada Life PlanDirect, Blue Cross Conversion, typically with a 60-day window and no medical underwriting, ensuring seamless coverage.
Can I switch group insurance providers without affecting employee coverage?
Yes, you can switch group insurance providers without disrupting employee coverage if the transition is managed properly. Employers should plan the change carefully, align start dates of the new plan with the termination date of the old plan, and work with an experienced group benefits broker.
Coordinating data transfer between providers and communicating early with employees ensures no coverage gaps. Proper planning keeps claims active and maintains employee trust throughout the process.
What mistakes should employers avoid when switching group insurance providers?
Switching group benefits providers can lead to cost savings and improved employee satisfaction, but certain mistakes can result in coverage gaps and unnecessary stress. Avoid these common errors when switching group insurance providers in Canada:
- Missing termination notice deadlines: Failing to notify your current provider on time can result in penalties, overlapping premiums, or automatic renewals
- Choosing based only on price: Selecting the cheapest option may compromise coverage quality, customer service, and digital features employees need
- Ignoring employee needs and feedback: Failing to consider what employees value most can lead to dissatisfaction and low engagement with the plan
- Skipping detailed plan comparison: Overlooking benefits like wellness programs, virtual care, and easy claims processing can reduce the plan’s effectiveness
- Failing to communicate with employees: Lack of clear, timely communication about the new plan creates confusion and reduces trust in the change
- Not seeking the help of an insurance advisor: Trying to switch group insurance providers all by yourself can lead to coverage gaps and errors in transition. Relying on an experienced group insurance advisor (such as our experts at PolicyAdvisor) can truly make the process of switching group insurance in Canada seamless and efficient
Frequently asked questions
Can I switch group insurance providers mid-year in Canada?
Yes, you can change your group insurance provider mid-year, but timing and notice periods matter. Most group insurance contracts in Canada have renewal dates, and switching outside this period may involve penalties or short-rate cancellation charges.
To avoid issues, review your current contract’s termination terms and provide proper notice to your insurer. Working with an experienced broker helps manage the transition smoothly, ensuring continuous coverage for employees without gaps, even if the switch happens mid-policy year.
Is it worth switching group insurance providers in Canada?
Switching providers is worth it if your current plan no longer meets your company’s needs. Common reasons include rising premiums without added value, poor claims service, limited flexibility, and a lack of digital tools.
A new provider can offer cost savings, enhanced wellness programs, and better technology. It also improves employee satisfaction and retention. Before switching, compare multiple quotes, review plan options, and ensure the new provider aligns with your business goals and workforce demographics for maximum benefit.
Do employees lose benefits when employers switch group insurance providers?
Employees do not typically lose benefits when employers switch providers, as coverage is continuous if the transition is well-planned. However, certain elements like deductibles, pre-existing condition clauses, or optional coverages may change.
Employers should clearly communicate these differences and provide conversion options for life, health, or critical illness insurance if needed. Proper coordination between old and new providers ensures no coverage gaps.
Why is poor claims service a reason to switch providers?
Slow claims processing, delayed reimbursements, and hard-to-reach customer service frustrate employees and reduce trust in your benefits program. A provider that lacks dedicated support or efficient systems can make simple claims complicated.
Modern insurers in Canada offer digital claims submission, quick turnaround times, and 24/7 assistance. If your employees face frequent delays or errors, switching to a provider with a better claims experience can boost confidence and engagement with your plan.
Canadian businesses should consider switching group insurance providers if they face rising premiums without added benefits, low employee satisfaction, poor claims processing, limited flexibility, or a lack of digital tools and wellness programs. A strong group plan should offer comprehensive coverage, competitive pricing, and easy claims management. If these needs aren’t met, employers can switch providers within 30–60 days by assessing their current plan, working with an experienced group benefits broker, comparing quotes, and coordinating the transition to avoid coverage gaps. Clear communication with employees and avoiding mistakes like ignoring feedback or focusing only on price ensures a smooth switch and improved benefits.
“Employee Benefits Statistics in Canada.” Made in CA.
